ALICE vs Nialli
Two scheduling tools that sit at different levels of the plan, so not like-for-like (our reading). ALICE is AI-first scheduling software that takes a Primavera P6 or Microsoft Project schedule and simulates many construction scenarios to optimize, de-risk and recover it, with schedule quality checks and an agent you can chat with. Nialli Visual Planner is digital pull planning on the Last Planner System: trades build and status the short-interval plan together on touch displays or their own devices, with PPC and reasons-for-variance tracking. Desk research from vendor sites read Nov 13, 2026; no winner.
In short: ALICE (Scheduling; no public prices (quote / sales)) vs Nialli (Digital pull planning; vendor publishes prices). Facts last checked ALICE Nov 19, 2026; Nialli Nov 18, 2026. No winner declared; desk research from vendor sites.
Side by side
| Sheet row | ALICE | Nialli |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Scheduling | Digital pull planning |
| AI role (our label) | AI-first | Not AI-first |
| What it does | AI construction scheduling software that simulates many scenarios to optimize, de-risk and recover schedules, at bid stage and during construction. The vendor calls this "generative scheduling", with what-if exploration of construction scenarios. Products listed: ALICE Optimize (including Targeted Optimization, finding the fastest path to a schedule acceleration target), ALICE Analyze (a single view of project and portfolio health), ALICE Model (baseline from a 3D model) and ALICE FieldPlan (In Beta; lookaheads connected to drawings), plus a Schedule Insights Agent / Construction Schedule Agent for chatting with a schedule and a Schedule Quality Score that says what to fix and why. A November 4, 2026 ALICE help-center article describes ALICE Agent, available to all ALICE Optimize users: on the Plan page you describe schedule changes in plain language (logic cleanup, crew and resource loading, calendars and workweeks, bulk task edits), it lists the proposed actions for review and changes nothing until you accept them, and the article says your data is not used to train the AI model (vendor statement). Its DCMA Schedule Check runs a DCMA 14-point quality check plus additional analysis on uploaded P6 or Microsoft Project schedules (missing relationships, unrealistic durations, critical path problems) with a scorecard, re-running each time a schedule is generated or optimized. Imports Microsoft Project, Oracle Primavera P6 and Primavera Cloud schedules. Project types named: industrial (energy, data centers, battery plants, chemical plants, mines, pipelines), civil and transit (railways, metros, highways, bridges, tunnels, viaducts) and buildings. The FAQ says the platform is SOC 2 Type II compliant and Cyber Essentials Plus certified, data is encrypted in transit and at rest, and customers own their data (vendor statements). Deployment-value figures are vendor claims not used here. | Visual Planner, construction planning software built on the Last Planner System for digital pull planning; free trial offered. Nialli Inc. is a wholly owned subsidiary of Nureva Inc. of Calgary, which formed it in September 2020 (Nialli press releases). The homepage says milestones and activities can be imported from Oracle Primavera P6, Asta Powerproject, Microsoft Project or a CSV; Percent Plan Complete (PPC) and reasons-for-variance data generate as teams status tasks; constraints show as warning dots on affected tasks; dependencies are drawn as arrows between cards with red indicators for downstream impacts; a staging area lets field teams queue tasks from a phone before a planning meeting; tasks are marked done with a twist gesture on a touchscreen; up to three connected touch displays can share one plan; and remote users join from a laptop, tablet or phone. Support pages say a Not done activity requires a reason for variance, PPC is done activities divided by committed activities, and reports and all plan data export to PDF and Power BI for portfolio reporting; the FAQ says large projects are best split across several plans. The navigation lists a Data centers industry page. |
| Who it's for | Owners, contractors, and consultants. Pricing FAQ says it is most often used by GCs and owners in infrastructure, industrial, and commercial sectors, generally on projects of at least $75M construction value. | Construction managers and jobsite teams. |
| Pricing (as publicly stated) | No public prices. The pricing page says "Start here to request a custom quote of ALICE", with a questionnaire (company type, project size, construction value of your average project, priorities, location) followed by a consultation call to share tailored pricing; no figures. Pricing is based on the size and scope of your projects, with unlimited users and unlimited data. The FAQ says the price covers the platform plus dedicated customer success time, and that ALICE is generally used on projects with a construction value of at least $75M. Confirm pricing with the vendor. | Vendor-listed pricing (pricing page): Single-plan subscription $1,400 per year (USD), a flat price not tied to company size, revenue or project metrics, with any number of users, core features and basic support (one plan supports up to 25 lanes of activity); Multiplan subscription with volume pricing via Contact sales, which the page says covers SSO and APIs; 30-day full-access free trial, no credit card. A Getting Started support package is included and a Project Enablement package is recommended, without prices. The FAQ says direct purchase is offered in Australia, Canada, the EU, New Zealand, the UK and the US with data residency in those regions, credit card purchasing is available in the United States and Canada, and Nialli does not sell hardware. Confirm current terms with the vendor. |
| User reviews | No reviews yet. Read or write | No reviews yet. Read or write |
| Vendor links | ||
| Sources |
|
Facts last checked: ALICE Nov 19, 2026; Nialli Nov 18, 2026. Prices change; check the vendor page before relying on them.
Where the vendor descriptions differ
- Level of the plan: ALICE works on the master schedule. It optimizes an existing P6 or Microsoft Project schedule (ALICE Optimize, including Targeted Optimization toward an acceleration target), scores portfolio health (ALICE Analyze) and can build a baseline from a 3D model (ALICE Model). Nialli works below the master schedule: milestones and activities are imported from P6, Asta Powerproject, Microsoft Project or a CSV, and field teams pull-plan the work between them.
- Who does the planning: in ALICE, schedulers and project controls staff run scenarios and what-if exploration; the vendor calls this generative scheduling. In Nialli, trades and superintendents add, move and status activity cards themselves, with color-coded trade tags, drag-and-drop and touch gestures, and Nialli says most users are productive within 10 minutes.
- Lookaheads: the closest overlap. ALICE lists FieldPlan, marked In Beta, for ready-to-execute field plans made from your drawings. Nialli's whole product is the collaborative field plan, with constraints shown as yellow warning dots on affected tasks and up to three connected touch displays sharing one plan for Big Room sessions.
- Checks and metrics: ALICE runs a DCMA 14-point check plus additional analysis (missing relationships, unrealistic durations, critical path problems) on uploaded schedules, with a Schedule Quality Score and a scorecard that re-runs when a schedule is generated or optimized. Nialli generates Percent Plan Complete (PPC) and reasons-for-variance data automatically as teams status their tasks.
- AI labels: ALICE is tagged AI-first, with a Schedule Insights Agent for chatting with a schedule. Nialli is tagged Not AI-first; the pages we read do not describe AI features.
- Project size: ALICE's pricing FAQ says it is generally used on projects of at least $75M construction value, most often by GCs and owners in infrastructure, industrial and commercial work. Nialli's pricing page calls its single-plan subscription perfect for small and mid-sized projects, and its FAQ says large projects are best split across several plans.
- Pricing (read Nov 13, 2026): Nialli publishes a single-plan subscription at $1,400 a year (USD) with any number of users, plus a 30-day free trial with no credit card; multiplan volume pricing, SSO and APIs go through sales. ALICE publishes no prices: a questionnaire and consultation call lead to a custom quote based on project size and scope, with unlimited users and data. See each tool page for detail.
- Not used here: ALICE's deployment-value and acceleration figures and Nialli's customer quotes (vendor material). Facts for both tools come from vendor websites (desk research).
Paraphrased from the sources listed above. Vendor claims are reported as claims.
What users say
The facts above come from vendor websites. Whether either tool is any good for your work is something only people who use them can say. These are member reviews, all ratings shown, never edited or removed for being negative.
ALICE
No reviews yet. Used ALICE? Yours would be the first.
Nialli
No reviews yet. Used Nialli? Yours would be the first.
Used either of these? Share your take
Good or bad, an honest review from an estimator, PM or super helps the next team more than another vendor demo. You post under a handle; your email is never shown.
Questions to ask in your review
- Whether your gap is a master schedule that needs optimizing or recovering (closer to ALICE) or weekly trade coordination in the field (closer to Nialli)
- When ALICE FieldPlan leaves beta and how it compares with a Last Planner workflow
- Whether Nialli plans and ALICE scenarios can be kept in step from the same P6 schedule
- Facts here come from vendor websites; confirm with each vendor before you buy
- What did you use it for, on what kind of work and project size?
- How long did setup and training take, and who on your team did it?
How reviews work: review guidelines and methodology. All reviews: reviews hub.
Related
- Category hub: Preconstruction management & AI scheduling tools
- Compare: ALICE vs nPlan
- Compare: ALICE vs Karmen
- Compare: nPlan vs SmartPM
- Compare: Outbuild vs Planera
- Compare: Karmen vs Planera
- Compare: Outbuild vs SmartPM
- Compare: SmartPM vs Document Crunch
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs SmartPM
- Compare: Nodes & Links vs Foresight
- Compare: Foresight vs nPlan
- Compare: Nialli vs BlackHyve
- Compare: cmBuilder vs PLOT
- Compare: Nialli vs Outbuild
- Compare: Planera vs SmartPM
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: BlackHyve vs blade ai
- Compare: Foresight vs SmartPM
- Compare: Karmen vs Foresight
- Compare: nPlan vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: ALICE vs Outbuild
- Compare: Nodes & Links vs SmartPM
- Compare: Karmen vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: Nialli vs Planera
- Compare: Karmen vs SmartPM: AI schedule building or schedule analytics
- Compare: Karmen vs nPlan
- Compare: ALICE vs SmartPM
- Compare: Outbuild vs nPlan
- Compare: ALICE vs Planera
- Compare: Karmen vs Outbuild
- Compare: ALICE vs Foresight
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs Foresight
- Compare: Buildots vs nPlan
- Compare: Planera vs nPlan
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs nPlan
- Compare: Karmen vs Steelray Delay Analyzer
- Compare: SmartPM vs Buildots
- Compare: Nodes & Links vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Nodes & Links vs ALICE
- Compare: Outbuild vs Foresight
- Compare: Planera vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs Planera
- Compare: Foresight vs Planera
- Compare: Nialli vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: Outbuild vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: ALICE vs Steelray Delay Analyzer
- Compare: cmBuilder vs ALICE
- Compare: Nialli vs Karmen
- Compare: BlackHyve vs SmartPM
- Compare: Enlaye vs nPlan
- Compare: Buildots vs Foresight
- Compare: Nialli vs cmBuilder
- Compare: Ontollo vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: Outbuild vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Karmen vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Nialli vs nPlan
- Compare: Outbuild vs cmBuilder
- Compare: Nialli vs SmartPM
- Compare: Planera vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Foresight vs BlackHyve
- Compare: nPlan vs BlackHyve