Nialli vs Karmen
Two scheduling tools for different parts of planning the work, so only partly like-for-like (our reading). Nialli's Visual Planner is digital pull planning built on the Last Planner System, with shared touchscreen boards, Percent Plan Complete and reasons for variance, and a published $1,400 a year Single-plan price. Karmen is an AI scheduling co-pilot, steered in plain language, that reads drawings, specs and past schedules to build, update and analyze CPM schedules and exports to Primavera P6 and Microsoft Project. Desk research from vendor sites read Nov 11, 2026; no winner.
In short: Nialli (Digital pull planning; vendor publishes prices) vs Karmen (AI scheduling co-pilot; no public prices (quote / sales)). Facts last checked Nov 18, 2026. No winner declared; desk research from vendor sites.
Side by side
| Sheet row | Nialli | Karmen |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Digital pull planning | AI scheduling co-pilot |
| AI role (our label) | Not AI-first | AI-first |
| What it does | Visual Planner, construction planning software built on the Last Planner System for digital pull planning; free trial offered. Nialli Inc. is a wholly owned subsidiary of Nureva Inc. of Calgary, which formed it in September 2020 (Nialli press releases). The homepage says milestones and activities can be imported from Oracle Primavera P6, Asta Powerproject, Microsoft Project or a CSV; Percent Plan Complete (PPC) and reasons-for-variance data generate as teams status tasks; constraints show as warning dots on affected tasks; dependencies are drawn as arrows between cards with red indicators for downstream impacts; a staging area lets field teams queue tasks from a phone before a planning meeting; tasks are marked done with a twist gesture on a touchscreen; up to three connected touch displays can share one plan; and remote users join from a laptop, tablet or phone. Support pages say a Not done activity requires a reason for variance, PPC is done activities divided by committed activities, and reports and all plan data export to PDF and Power BI for portfolio reporting; the FAQ says large projects are best split across several plans. The navigation lists a Data centers industry page. | AI scheduling co-pilot, steered in natural language, that reads project documents to build new schedules, update existing ones and analyze changes. It reads drawings, specs, historic schedules and templates in P6, MSP or XER; new schedules include WBS, activities and CPM logic links; updates include time-impact analysis with structured fragnets; and analysis tracks float and critical-path movement between monthly updates. Exports to Primavera P6 and Microsoft Project. Vendor says it learns from your historic schedules and reads thousands of pages in minutes (vendor claims, not verified). Security: vendor says SOC 2 reports are shared on request, data is encrypted in transit and at rest, and project documents are never used to train shared models. Y Combinator batch: Fall 2024 (YC company profile). Customer quotes are not used. |
| Who it's for | Construction managers and jobsite teams. | Schedulers, superintendents, and general and specialty contractors who own a project timeline (vendor quotes a GC scheduling director and superintendents). |
| Pricing (as publicly stated) | Vendor-listed pricing (pricing page): Single-plan subscription $1,400 per year (USD), a flat price not tied to company size, revenue or project metrics, with any number of users, core features and basic support (one plan supports up to 25 lanes of activity); Multiplan subscription with volume pricing via Contact sales, which the page says covers SSO and APIs; 30-day full-access free trial, no credit card. A Getting Started support package is included and a Project Enablement package is recommended, without prices. The FAQ says direct purchase is offered in Australia, Canada, the EU, New Zealand, the UK and the US with data residency in those regions, credit card purchasing is available in the United States and Canada, and Nialli does not sell hardware. Confirm current terms with the vendor. | Not publicly listed. The vendor site has no pricing or plans link, and /pricing and /plans return a not-found page. The site offers Book a demo and Talk to us. Confirm pricing with the vendor. |
| User reviews | No reviews yet. Read or write | No reviews yet. Read or write |
| Vendor links | ||
| Sources |
|
Facts last checked: Nov 18, 2026. Prices change; check the vendor page before relying on them.
Where the vendor descriptions differ
- Where they sit: Nialli is used by the team in the planning meeting and on the jobsite board, turning milestones into a pull plan and tracking commitments. Karmen is used by whoever owns the CPM schedule to draft new schedules with WBS, activities and logic links, revise them as scope changes and compare monthly updates (vendor descriptions).
- Schedule files: Nialli imports milestones and activities from Primavera P6, Asta Powerproject, Microsoft Project or a CSV, and exports reports and plan data to PDF and Power BI. Karmen reads historic schedules and templates in P6, MSP or XER and exports to Primavera P6 and Microsoft Project.
- Tracking and change: Nialli generates Percent Plan Complete and reasons-for-variance data as teams status tasks, shows constraints as warning dots and draws dependencies as arrows with red indicators for downstream impacts. Karmen lists time-impact analysis with structured fragnets for schedule updates and tracks float and critical-path movement between monthly updates.
- AI: Nialli is tagged Not AI-first in our directory; the pages read describe no AI features. Karmen is AI-first and says it learns from your historic schedules to sequence work (vendor claim).
- Security (vendor statements): Nialli publishes a corporate security practices page and its FAQ lists data residency in the regions where it sells. Karmen shares SOC 2 reports on request, encrypts data in transit and at rest, and says project documents are never used to train shared models.
- Pricing: Nialli publishes a Single-plan subscription at $1,400 per year (USD) with any number of users (one plan supports up to 25 lanes of activity), a Multiplan subscription via Contact sales and a 30-day free trial with no credit card. Karmen publishes no prices and offers Book a demo and Talk to us. Both read Nov 11, 2026; see each tool page for detail.
- Not used here: customer quotes from both vendor sites and Karmen's speed and page-count claims (vendor material). Facts for both tools come from vendor websites (desk research).
Paraphrased from the sources listed above. Vendor claims are reported as claims.
What users say
The facts above come from vendor websites. Whether either tool is any good for your work is something only people who use them can say. These are member reviews, all ratings shown, never edited or removed for being negative.
Nialli
No reviews yet. Used Nialli? Yours would be the first.
Karmen
No reviews yet. Used Karmen? Yours would be the first.
Used either of these? Share your take
Good or bad, an honest review from an estimator, PM or super helps the next team more than another vendor demo. You post under a handle; your email is never shown.
Questions to ask in your review
- Whether your need is running weekly pull planning with the field (closer to Nialli) or drafting and updating the CPM schedule faster (closer to Karmen), or both
- How a Karmen-built schedule would carry into a Nialli pull plan, and back into P6 or Microsoft Project
- What Karmen costs for your number of projects or schedulers
- What did you use it for, on what kind of work and project size?
- How long did setup and training take, and who on your team did it?
- What does it cost you in practice, compared with what the sales call said?
How reviews work: review guidelines and methodology. All reviews: reviews hub.
Related
- Category hub: Preconstruction management & AI scheduling tools
- Compare: ALICE vs nPlan
- Compare: ALICE vs Karmen
- Compare: nPlan vs SmartPM
- Compare: Outbuild vs Planera
- Compare: Karmen vs Planera
- Compare: Outbuild vs SmartPM
- Compare: SmartPM vs Document Crunch
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs SmartPM
- Compare: Nodes & Links vs Foresight
- Compare: Foresight vs nPlan
- Compare: Nialli vs BlackHyve
- Compare: cmBuilder vs PLOT
- Compare: Nialli vs Outbuild
- Compare: Planera vs SmartPM
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: BlackHyve vs blade ai
- Compare: Foresight vs SmartPM
- Compare: Karmen vs Foresight
- Compare: nPlan vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: ALICE vs Outbuild
- Compare: Nodes & Links vs SmartPM
- Compare: Karmen vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: Nialli vs Planera
- Compare: Karmen vs SmartPM: AI schedule building or schedule analytics
- Compare: Karmen vs nPlan
- Compare: ALICE vs SmartPM
- Compare: Outbuild vs nPlan
- Compare: ALICE vs Planera
- Compare: Karmen vs Outbuild
- Compare: ALICE vs Foresight
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs Foresight
- Compare: Buildots vs nPlan
- Compare: Planera vs nPlan
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs nPlan
- Compare: Karmen vs Steelray Delay Analyzer
- Compare: SmartPM vs Buildots
- Compare: Nodes & Links vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Nodes & Links vs ALICE
- Compare: Outbuild vs Foresight
- Compare: Planera vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs Planera
- Compare: Foresight vs Planera
- Compare: Nialli vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: Outbuild vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: ALICE vs Steelray Delay Analyzer
- Compare: cmBuilder vs ALICE
- Compare: BlackHyve vs SmartPM
- Compare: ALICE vs Nialli
- Compare: Enlaye vs nPlan
- Compare: Buildots vs Foresight
- Compare: Nialli vs cmBuilder
- Compare: Ontollo vs Nodes & Links
- Compare: Outbuild vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Steelray Delay Analyzer vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Karmen vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Nialli vs nPlan
- Compare: Outbuild vs cmBuilder
- Compare: Nialli vs SmartPM
- Compare: Planera vs BlackHyve
- Compare: Foresight vs BlackHyve
- Compare: nPlan vs BlackHyve