Lumber vs MobiClocks
Two construction workforce tools that approach time, payroll and compliance from different angles. Lumber is an AI-first payroll, HR and field-operations platform with Agent Center agents for certified payroll, unions and related compliance that can run on top of an existing ERP or HCM. MobiClocks is face-recognition time and attendance with geofencing, cost coding and Davis-Bacon certified payroll management, published at Core $9 per user/month (Enterprise via sales). Partly like-for-like (our reading): both help contractors capture labor time and support certified/union payroll workflows; Lumber leans AI agents across payroll/HR/compliance, while MobiClocks leans biometric clock-in and punch integrity. Desk research from vendor sites read Nov 6, 2026; no winner.
In short: Lumber (Construction payroll, HR & workforce; no public prices (quote / sales)) vs MobiClocks (Face-recognition time & attendance; vendor publishes prices). Facts last checked Nov 18, 2026. No winner declared; desk research from vendor sites.
Side by side
| Sheet row | Lumber | MobiClocks |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Construction payroll, HR & workforce | Face-recognition time & attendance |
| AI role (our label) | AI-first | Not AI-first |
| What it does | Construction workforce platform for payroll, HR, compliance and field operations, with AI agents for certified payroll and other compliance work. The vendor describes it as "Built for Construction. Powered by AI." and lists a free AI audit tool and a feature that turns collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) into AI insights you can chat with. Menus list payroll (prevailing wages, union payroll and reporting, certified payroll, workers' compensation, tax filing, remittances, Record of Employment), field operations (time tracking, schedule and dispatch, equipment and productivity tracking, form builder, job costing, safety) and HR and benefits (applicant tracking, onboarding, credential management, a learning management system). Its Agent Center lists Union, Certified Payroll Reporting, Funding, Certificate of Insurance, Paper Timecard, Union Reporting, Apprentice Ratio, Workers' Comp and tax notice agents that it says can run on top of an existing ERP or HCM (Acumatica, Sage, Viewpoint, Procore, Knowify, ServiceTitan, ADP, Workday, COINS) by API or CSV/file upload, routing exceptions to a person when rules conflict or data is incomplete; LumberCare pairs CPAs and prevailing wage specialists with the agents. The certified payroll page lists WH-347 automation, wage determinations applied by location, classification, craft and contract schedule, validation of rates, fringes, overtime, classification and apprentice rates before reports are generated, AI scanning for missing entries or anomalies, and PDF, XML or CSV export for LCP, DIR, eMars and Elation. The vendor says customer data is never used to train third-party AI models and that Lumber is SOC 2 Type II audited (vendor statements). Menus also list financial services (workers' compensation insurance, on-demand pay and earned wage access). The site serves region-specific US and Canadian content; the Canadian version describes Canadian payroll. The processing-time percentage is a vendor claim and is not used. | Workforce management with face-recognition time clocks to prevent buddy punching and streamline payroll. The pricing page lists on all plans: facial recognition clock in/out, geofencing and optional GPS breadcrumbing (administrators can turn it on or off; it stops at punch-out), offline punches for remote sites, unlimited free kiosk and personal apps, customizable clock-in and clock-out attestation, lunch and break policies, drag-and-drop cost coding, production tracking, subcontractor time tracking, certification tracking, Davis-Bacon certified payroll management, per-diem calculations, advanced union overtime policies, suspicious activity flagging and a GC reporting dashboard (MobiLink); the Enterprise plan adds workforce scheduling, a jobsite monitoring dashboard and a resource request and assignment workflow. The homepage says its kiosk and personal apps compare the worker's face with a profile photo on file using facial recognition algorithms, punches are allowed only inside a radial or custom geofence by default (configurable), and missed, offline and failed punches are flagged on the dashboard. Apps support English, Spanish and French. The pages we read do not describe the face matching as AI, so we keep the Not AI-first tag. Customer stories and quotes are not used. |
| Who it's for | Subcontractors through multi-state enterprise contractors. | Construction companies with large labor forces. |
| Pricing (as publicly stated) | No public plan prices: /pricing returns a not-found page. Lumber's Agent Center FAQ says Premium Agents are a flat monthly fee based on the agent's complexity and the size of information processed, with bundle pricing for more than one agent and a quote based on workforce and agents chosen (contact the vendor for a number). The homepage markup carries a holiday offer of up to 15% off all modules. Confirm current pricing with the vendor. | Vendor-listed pricing (pricing page; renders in a headless browser): Core $9 per user/month, described as for most companies up to 500 people; Enterprise for 500+ employees via Talk to an Expert, minimum of 50 users. 30-day free trial; the page notes direct payroll integrations may have additional expense. Confirm current terms with the vendor. |
| User reviews | No reviews yet. Read or write | No reviews yet. Read or write |
| Vendor links | ||
| Sources |
Facts last checked: Nov 18, 2026. Prices change; check the vendor page before relying on them.
Where the vendor descriptions differ
- Job shape: Lumber menus list payroll (prevailing wages, union, certified payroll, workers' comp, tax filing), field operations (time tracking, schedule and dispatch, equipment and productivity, forms, job costing, safety) and HR/benefits (ATS, onboarding, credentials, LMS), plus Agent Center agents (Union, Certified Payroll Reporting, Funding, COI, Paper Timecard, Union Reporting, Apprentice Ratio, Workers' Comp and tax notices) that can sit on Acumatica, Sage, Viewpoint, Procore, Knowify, ServiceTitan, ADP, Workday or COINS by API or file upload. MobiClocks plans list facial recognition clock in/out, geofencing and optional GPS breadcrumbing, offline punches, unlimited free kiosk and personal apps, attestation, lunch/break policies, cost coding, production tracking, subcontractor time, certification tracking, Davis-Bacon certified payroll, per-diems, union overtime policies, suspicious-activity flagging and a GC reporting dashboard (MobiLink); Enterprise adds workforce scheduling, a jobsite monitoring dashboard and resource request/assignment.
- AI / recognition: Lumber markets AI agents and a free AI audit tool, plus CBA chat insights; it says customer data is never used to train third-party AI models (vendor statement). MobiClocks describes face matching against a profile photo with facial recognition algorithms; the pages we read do not call that AI, so its directory tag stays Not AI-first.
- Who it's for: Lumber positions construction payroll/HR/field ops for growing contractors (US and Canadian site variants). MobiClocks positions construction and field employers needing punch integrity, including Core for most companies up to 500 people and Enterprise for 500+.
- Pricing (read Nov 6, 2026): Lumber publishes no plan prices (/pricing not found); Premium Agents are a flat monthly fee by agent complexity and data size, with bundle pricing, via quote; homepage markup still carries up to 15% off all modules this holiday season. MobiClocks publishes Core $9/user/month and Enterprise talk-to-an-expert (min. 50 users), 30-day free trial; direct payroll integrations may cost extra. See each tool page for detail.
- Not used here: processing-time percentages, ghost-employee dollar examples, customer stories and quotes from either vendor (vendor material). Facts for both tools come from vendor websites (desk research).
Paraphrased from the sources listed above. Vendor claims are reported as claims.
What users say
The facts above come from vendor websites. Whether either tool is any good for your work is something only people who use them can say. These are member reviews, all ratings shown, never edited or removed for being negative.
Lumber
No reviews yet. Used Lumber? Yours would be the first.
MobiClocks
No reviews yet. Used MobiClocks? Yours would be the first.
Used either of these? Share your take
Good or bad, an honest review from an estimator, PM or super helps the next team more than another vendor demo. You post under a handle; your email is never shown.
Questions to ask in your review
- Whether your priority is AI-assisted certified/union payroll and HR on top of an ERP (Lumber) or biometric, geofenced punch capture feeding payroll (MobiClocks), or both
- What Lumber quotes for agents/modules on your workforce size, and whether MobiClocks Core or Enterprise fits your headcount and scheduling needs
- How each one's certified-payroll export and payroll/ERP integrations behave on your own jobs
- What did you use it for, on what kind of work and project size?
- How long did setup and training take, and who on your team did it?
- What does it cost you in practice, compared with what the sales call said?
How reviews work: review guidelines and methodology. All reviews: reviews hub.
Related
- Category hub: Workforce planning & staffing tools
- Compare: HammerTech vs WakeCap
- Compare: Kwant.ai vs WakeCap
- Compare: SmartBarrel vs MobiClocks
- Compare: Procore Resource Planning (LaborChart) vs Bridgit
- Compare: Assignar vs Procore Resource Planning
- Compare: HammerTech vs SafetyClerk
- Compare: Eyrus vs Kwant.ai
- Compare: busybusy vs MobiClocks
- Compare: Lumber vs Miter
- Compare: LCPtracker vs Miter
- Compare: innDex vs MSite
- Compare: mJob vs MobiClocks
- Compare: HR Duo vs Lumber
- Compare: Pinnacle Series vs BuildWitt Improve
- Compare: SmartBarrel vs mJob
- Compare: Assignar vs Bridgit
- Compare: Eyrus vs MSite
- Compare: HR Duo vs BuildWitt Improve
- Compare: GRAITEC vs Pinnacle Series
- Compare: Eyrus vs WakeCap
- Compare: LCPtracker vs Lumber
- Compare: mJob vs Rhumbix
- Compare: Kwant.ai vs SafetyClerk
- Compare: Eyrus vs HammerTech
- Compare: SmartBarrel vs Workyard
- Compare: Assignar vs Eyrus
- Compare: Eyrus vs SmartBarrel
- Compare: BiltOn vs Eyrus
- Compare: MobiClocks vs Workyard
- Compare: Assignar vs Crewscope
- Compare: Crewscope vs HR Duo
- Compare: Kwant.ai vs HammerTech
- Compare: ClockShark vs MobiClocks
- Compare: HammerTech vs MSite
- Compare: mJob vs ClockShark
- Compare: SkillSignal vs SmartBarrel
- Compare: Bridgit vs mJob
- Compare: Kwant.ai vs innDex
- Compare: Trayd vs Lumber
- Compare: Kwant vs MSite
- Compare: Assignar vs mJob
- Compare: ClockShark vs SmartBarrel
- Compare: Arcoro Time vs MobiClocks
- Compare: WakeCap vs MSite
- Compare: SafetyClerk vs Eyrus
- Compare: Assignar vs Workyard
- Compare: Eyrus vs MobiClocks
- Compare: MobiClocks vs Kwant.ai
- Compare: Procore Resource Planning vs MobiClocks
- Compare: HR Duo vs innDex
- Compare: Procore Resource Planning vs HR Duo
- Compare: Rhumbix vs MobiClocks
- Compare: Eyrus vs innDex
- Compare: HR Duo vs Miter
- Compare: MobiClocks vs MSite
- Compare: Kwant.ai vs SmartBarrel
- Compare: WakeCap vs innDex
- Compare: BuildWitt Improve vs SafetyClerk
- Compare: Dili vs Lumber
- Compare: Eyrus vs Miter
- Compare: SkillSignal vs Kwant.ai
- Compare: Bridgit vs HR Duo
- Compare: Eyrus vs EquipmentShare T3
- Compare: IMAGINiT vs Pinnacle Series
- Compare: HCSS HeavyJob vs mJob
- Compare: Eyrus vs Lumber
- Compare: Workyard vs Lumber
- Compare: SmartBarrel vs WakeCap
- Compare: LCPtracker vs MobiClocks
- Compare: BuildWitt Improve vs SkillSignal
- Compare: Crewscope vs WakeCap
- Compare: Procore Resource Planning (LaborChart) vs Workyard
- Compare: WakeCap vs MobiClocks
- Compare: Bridgit vs Lumber
- Compare: BuildWitt Improve vs HammerTech
- Compare: Crewscope vs mJob
- Compare: SafetyClerk vs MSite (Infobric)
- Compare: SmartBarrel vs MSite (Infobric)
- Compare: Assignar vs Rhumbix
- Compare: busybusy vs Lumber
- Compare: HR Duo vs Kwant.ai
- Compare: innDex vs Assignar
- Compare: Lumber vs Assignar
- Compare: Kwant.ai vs mJob
- Compare: Bridgit vs WakeCap
- Compare: HammerTech vs Assignar
- Compare: mJob vs Lumber
- Compare: SmartBarrel vs Lumber
- Compare: Assignar vs ClockShark
- Compare: Eyrus vs Breadcrumb
- Compare: HR Duo vs SmartBarrel
- Compare: Kwant.ai vs Lumber
- Compare: mJob vs LCPtracker
- Compare: SafetyClerk vs MobiClocks
- Compare: SmartBarrel vs LCPtracker
- Compare: Trayd vs HR Duo
- Compare: Breadcrumb vs MSite
- Compare: Eyrus vs Rhumbix
- Compare: Kwant.ai vs Assignar
- Compare: Miter vs MobiClocks
- Compare: Assignar vs Arcoro Time (ExakTime)
- Compare: ClockShark vs Lumber
- Compare: Eyrus vs LCPtracker