Means & Methods Lab, home
Facts: desk research from vendor sites · Reviews: members' opinions

ClockShark vs Lumber

Two ways to get crew hours from the field into payroll, at different scopes, so not like-for-like (our reading). ClockShark is a GPS time-tracking and crew-scheduling app for small and mid-size construction and field service businesses that feeds payroll and job costing through integrations, with published plans; Lumber is a construction workforce platform that runs payroll, HR, compliance and field operations itself, with AI agents for certified payroll and union reporting, sold by quote. Desk research from vendor sites read Nov 19, 2026; no winner.

DESK RESEARCH FROM VENDOR SITES. Compiled from vendors' public websites (accessed ClockShark Nov 19, 2026; Lumber Nov 18, 2026). Vendor claims are not verified by Means & Methods Lab. No scores or rankings.

In short: ClockShark (GPS time tracking & crew scheduling (with Lightning AI); vendor publishes prices) vs Lumber (Construction payroll, HR & workforce; no public prices (quote / sales)). Facts last checked ClockShark Nov 19, 2026; Lumber Nov 18, 2026. No winner declared; desk research from vendor sites.

Side by side

ClockShark vs Lumber: vendor-published facts side by side
Sheet rowClockSharkLumber
CategoryGPS time tracking & crew scheduling (with Lightning AI)Construction payroll, HR & workforce
AI role (our label)AI features added to established productAI-first
What it doesTime-tracking, scheduling and job-management app for construction and field service, with GPS clock-in, job costing and payroll integrations. Features listed: mobile and web clock in/out, GPS and geofencing, who's-working-now view, drag-and-drop scheduling and draft schedules, time off, job costing, job management, conversations, shift wrap-up and compliance forms, reports, built-in Spanish language support, and payroll/accounting integrations (QuickBooks, Sage 100 Contractor, Xero, ADP and Paychex named). ClockShark Lightning, which its Lightning page describes as AI inside the existing app, has one AI agent, JobReady, which composes a shift brief from the day's schedule, jobs, site notes, checklists and attachments when a crew member opens the app on a scheduled day, plus two standard (non-AI) features: Task Checklists (up to 20 timestamped items that appear at clock-in) and Mileage Tracking (miles entered at clock-out, CSV export; Pro). The vendor says JobReady only produces a brief and never changes a schedule, job or record on its own, that on-clock GPS collection is unchanged, and that customer data is not used to train AI models. The Company menu links an AI Pledge from Simpro Group (Simpro Software, ClockShark, AroFlo and BigChange) with principles on privacy, transparency, fairness, accountability and inclusivity, including not sharing customer data with third parties to train AI models without express permission (vendor statement). ClockShark's About page says it is part of the Simpro Group, alongside Simpro, BigChange and AroFlo. Company counts, accuracy claims and testimonials are vendor content and are not used.Construction workforce platform for payroll, HR, compliance and field operations, with AI agents for certified payroll and other compliance work. The vendor describes it as "Built for Construction. Powered by AI." and lists a free AI audit tool and a feature that turns collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) into AI insights you can chat with. Menus list payroll (prevailing wages, union payroll and reporting, certified payroll, workers' compensation, tax filing, remittances, Record of Employment), field operations (time tracking, schedule and dispatch, equipment and productivity tracking, form builder, job costing, safety) and HR and benefits (applicant tracking, onboarding, credential management, a learning management system). Its Agent Center lists Union, Certified Payroll Reporting, Funding, Certificate of Insurance, Paper Timecard, Union Reporting, Apprentice Ratio, Workers' Comp and tax notice agents that it says can run on top of an existing ERP or HCM (Acumatica, Sage, Viewpoint, Procore, Knowify, ServiceTitan, ADP, Workday, COINS) by API or CSV/file upload, routing exceptions to a person when rules conflict or data is incomplete; LumberCare pairs CPAs and prevailing wage specialists with the agents. The certified payroll page lists WH-347 automation, wage determinations applied by location, classification, craft and contract schedule, validation of rates, fringes, overtime, classification and apprentice rates before reports are generated, AI scanning for missing entries or anomalies, and PDF, XML or CSV export for LCP, DIR, eMars and Elation. The vendor says customer data is never used to train third-party AI models and that Lumber is SOC 2 Type II audited (vendor statements). Menus also list financial services (workers' compensation insurance, on-demand pay and earned wage access). The site serves region-specific US and Canadian content; the Canadian version describes Canadian payroll. The processing-time percentage is a vendor claim and is not used.
Who it's forSmall and mid-size construction and field service businesses that need crew time, GPS and scheduling feeding payroll and job costing.Subcontractors through multi-state enterprise contractors.
Pricing (as publicly stated)Vendor-listed USD prices (rendered pricing page): Standard $42/month plus $9.50 per user per month; Pro $63/month plus $11.50 per user per month (Pro adds PTO, multi-department controls, advanced job costing, shift wrap-up forms and mileage tracking). The page states a three-year contract term applies to all pricing plans; 14-day trial with Pro features; pro-rated billing for active users. JobReady and Task Checklists are on both plans; Mileage Tracking and JobSummary are on Pro (the pricing page lists JobSummary without a description, and the Lightning page does not cover it). Confirm current terms with the vendor.No public plan prices: /pricing returns a not-found page. Lumber's Agent Center FAQ says Premium Agents are a flat monthly fee based on the agent's complexity and the size of information processed, with bundle pricing for more than one agent and a quote based on workforce and agents chosen (contact the vendor for a number). The homepage markup carries a holiday offer of up to 15% off all modules. Confirm current pricing with the vendor.
User reviewsNo reviews yet. Read or writeNo reviews yet. Read or write
Vendor links
Sources

Facts last checked: ClockShark Nov 19, 2026; Lumber Nov 18, 2026. Prices change; check the vendor page before relying on them.

Where the vendor descriptions differ

  • Core job: ClockShark lists mobile and web clock in and out, GPS and geofencing, a who's-working-now view, drag-and-drop scheduling with draft schedules, time off, job costing and job management, conversations, shift wrap-up and compliance forms, reports and built-in Spanish. Lumber's menus list payroll (prevailing wages, union payroll and reporting, certified payroll, workers' compensation, tax filing and remittances), field operations (time tracking, schedule and dispatch, equipment and productivity tracking, a form builder, job costing and safety) and HR and benefits (applicant tracking, onboarding, credential management and a learning management system).
  • Payroll: ClockShark sends hours to payroll and accounting through integrations; it names QuickBooks, Sage 100 Contractor, Xero, ADP and Paychex. Lumber runs payroll itself, and its certified payroll page lists WH-347 automation, wage determinations applied by location, classification, craft and contract schedule, validation of rates, fringes, overtime and apprentice rates before reports are generated, and PDF, XML or CSV export for LCP, DIR, eMars and Elation.
  • AI (vendor statements): ClockShark Lightning has one AI agent, JobReady, which composes a shift brief from the day's schedule, jobs, site notes, checklists and attachments when a crew member opens the app on a scheduled day; ClockShark says it never changes a schedule, job or record on its own and that customer data is not used to train AI models. Lumber's Agent Center lists Union, Certified Payroll Reporting, Funding, Certificate of Insurance, Paper Timecard, Union Reporting, Apprentice Ratio, Workers' Comp and tax notice agents that it says can run on top of an existing ERP or HCM by API or file upload and route exceptions to a person; it says customer data is never used to train third-party AI models. Our directory labels ClockShark AI features added to established product and Lumber AI-first.
  • Company: ClockShark's About page says it is part of the Simpro Group, alongside Simpro, BigChange and AroFlo. Lumber states it is SOC 2 Type II audited (vendor statement) and serves region-specific US and Canadian content.
  • Who each names: ClockShark names small and mid-size construction and field service businesses. Lumber names subcontractors through multi-state enterprise contractors.
  • Pricing: ClockShark publishes USD prices: Standard $42 a month plus $9.50 per user per month and Pro $63 a month plus $11.50 per user per month, with a three-year contract term stated for all plans and a 14-day trial with Pro features. Lumber publishes no plan prices; its Agent Center FAQ says Premium Agents are a flat monthly fee based on the agent's complexity and the size of information processed, with bundle pricing and a quote based on workforce and agents chosen. See each tool page for detail.
  • Not used here: company counts, processing-time percentages, accuracy claims and testimonials (vendor material). Facts for both tools come from vendor websites (desk research).

Paraphrased from the sources listed above. Vendor claims are reported as claims.

What users say

The facts above come from vendor websites. Whether either tool is any good for your work is something only people who use them can say. These are member reviews, all ratings shown, never edited or removed for being negative.

Used either of these? Share your take

Good or bad, an honest review from an estimator, PM or super helps the next team more than another vendor demo. You post under a handle; your email is never shown.

Questions to ask in your review

  • Whether you need crew time, GPS and scheduling feeding the payroll you already run (closer to ClockShark) or a platform that runs construction payroll, certified payroll and union reporting itself (closer to Lumber)
  • How much prevailing-wage, union and certified payroll work your jobs carry
  • What Lumber's quote comes to for your workforce and agents, and whether ClockShark's three-year term suits you
  • Neither vendor's pages we read name the other or describe an integration
  • What did you use it for, on what kind of work and project size?
  • How long did setup and training take, and who on your team did it?

How reviews work: review guidelines and methodology. All reviews: reviews hub.

Related