Billy vs Highwire
Two subcontractor risk tools for general contractors that overlap at prequalification, with different centers of gravity, so this is partly like-for-like (our reading). Billy is a construction compliance platform centered on certificates of insurance, with an AI Review Assistant that checks COIs against your requirements, plus certified payroll, lien waivers, warranties and an embedded prequalification form. Highwire is contractor risk software built around prequalification assessments of company, finance, safety and insurance risk, with field safety applications; Veriforce announced it acquired Highwire in Oct 2025. Desk research from vendor sites (Billy last checked Nov 9, 2026; Highwire last checked Nov 8, 2026); no winner.
In short: Billy (COI & subcontractor compliance; vendor publishes prices) vs Highwire (Contractor prequalification & risk; no public prices (quote / sales)). Facts last checked Billy Nov 19, 2026; Highwire Nov 18, 2026. No winner declared; desk research from vendor sites.
Side by side
| Sheet row | Billy | Highwire |
|---|---|---|
| Category | COI & subcontractor compliance | Contractor prequalification & risk |
| AI role (our label) | AI features added to established product | Not AI-first |
| What it does | Construction compliance platform that the FAQ describes as all-in-one risk transfer and vendor compliance, from prequalification to closeout; the homepage says it is built exclusively for construction. Before award, subs apply through a prequalification form you embed on your own site (no account, login or fee), using your own questionnaire plus MSAs, safety records and financial documents, and approved vendors sync to Procore and your ERP. During a project it runs four workflows (certificates of insurance, certified payroll, lien waivers and warranties) and also tracks W-9s, business licenses, notices to owner, safety certifications and custom documents, set per project; vendors or their brokers upload through a secure link with no login, and renewal requests go out three months before expiry, one month before and on the expiration date. Compliance status syncs to accounting so non-compliant subs are held from payment (Sage Intacct, Sage 300, Viewpoint Vista, CMiC, Oracle JD Edwards and Acumatica). The AI Review Assistant scans an uploaded COI against your requirements and flags missing endorsements (such as CG 20 10, CG 20 37, waiver of subrogation and primary/noncontributory wording), missing additional insured language, limits below requirements, expired policies and missing umbrella or workers' compensation coverage, tells the vendor how to fix it, and offers a chat to clarify requirements. Plans are Self Service (your team uses the software and AI) or Managed Services (its CRIS-certified Certificate Management Team reviews every certificate and endorsement). The homepage also lists OCIP/CCIP wrap-up support, post-completion warranty tracking for 2, 5 or 10+ years, Procore Pay blocking, a Procore Side Panel and Microsoft Entra ID SSO; the FAQ names GCs, developers, owners, homebuilders, risk and compliance teams, subcontractors (Insurance Wallet), brokers, carriers and manufacturers. Integrations include Procore, Autodesk, CMiC, Sage 300, Sage Intacct, Viewpoint Vista, Oracle JD Edwards, Trimble ProjectSight, Acumatica and Docusign, with role-based permissions and free tools such as a W9 generator. Billy is a trademark of BuildAP, Inc. (Brooklyn, NY). Policy and project counts, review ratings and customer quotes are vendor content and are not used. | Contractor risk software built around prequalification assessments and field applications, covering company, finance, safety and insurance risk. The vendor frames it as moving beyond pass/fail document checklists to understanding each contractor's risks and working with subs to mitigate default and safety risks. Its prequalification page lists financial analysis, project capabilities, past project experience, diversity classifications, corporate information, surety bond tracking, litigation and defaults, safety performance history, client and supplier references, and expert third-party validation and QA, and says it helps GCs avoid costly defaults and meet SDI (subcontractor default insurance) prequalification requirements (vendor wording). Field applications cover Advanced Safety, Inspections and Incidents; integrations include Procore (syncing projects and contractors and monitoring contract spend) and a Companion integration option. Its one AI feature on the pages we read is AI Findings for Inspections, launched June 15, 2026: inspectors speak observations into the Highwire Inspections mobile app and AI generates structured findings with categories and risk levels, in full inspections or one-off findings. AI is not central to the product, so we tag it Not AI-first. Ownership: a Veriforce press release dated Oct 22, 2025 announces that Veriforce acquired Highwire and describes Highwire as a prequalification and contractor risk provider for the U.S. construction and capital projects market; Highwire's own press releases now call it a Veriforce company. Veriforce runs a cross-industry contractor network; see our Veriforce entry. Contractor counts and case-study results are vendor claims and are not used. |
| Who it's for | General contractors managing subcontractor insurance compliance. | General contractors' preconstruction and risk teams, and owners running capital projects (vendor wording). |
| Pricing (as publicly stated) | Vendor-listed starting price (FAQ): plans start as low as $500 a year, and pricing scales with the number of vendors you track and the plan you choose (Self Service or Managed Services); a free trial is available and the FAQ asks you to get a quote for your vendor count. /pricing returns a not-found page. Confirm current pricing with the vendor. | Not publicly listed: the site offers Get Pricing / Request a Demo forms. The pricing page FAQ says full pricing is not listed because client pricing depends on the assessment packages needed and the number of contractors you work with; clients can choose how assessments are paid for, contractor subscriptions are based on company headcount, and a free trial is offered for clients. Its cost-comparison claim against other systems is not used. Confirm pricing with the vendor. |
| User reviews | No reviews yet. Read or write | No reviews yet. Read or write |
| Vendor links | ||
| Sources |
|
Facts last checked: Billy Nov 19, 2026; Highwire Nov 18, 2026. Prices change; check the vendor page before relying on them.
Where the vendor descriptions differ
- Partly like-for-like: both help a GC decide which subs to trust and keep track of them, but Billy's core is ongoing document compliance during the project (insurance certificates and endorsements, certified payroll, lien waivers, warranties), while Highwire's core is assessing a contractor's financial, safety and default risk before award. Neither vendor names the other.
- Prequalification: Billy says subs apply through a prequalification form you embed on your own site, with no account, login or fee, using your own questionnaire plus MSAs, safety records and financial documents, and approved vendors sync to Procore and your ERP. Highwire lists financial analysis, project capabilities, past project experience, diversity classifications, surety bond tracking, litigation and defaults, safety performance history, references, and third-party validation and QA, and says it helps GCs meet subcontractor default insurance (SDI) prequalification requirements.
- Insurance and project compliance: Billy tracks COIs, W-9s, licenses, notices to owner and custom documents per project, sends renewal requests three months before expiry, one month before and on the expiration date, and syncs compliance status to accounting so non-compliant subs can be held from payment, with Procore Pay blocking. Highwire's prequalification covers insurance as one of four risk areas, and it adds field applications for Advanced Safety, Inspections and Incidents.
- AI: Billy's AI Review Assistant scans an uploaded COI against your requirements and flags missing endorsements, missing additional insured language, low limits, expired policies and missing umbrella or workers' compensation coverage, then tells the vendor how to fix it; Billy is tagged AI features added. Highwire's only AI feature on the pages we read is AI Findings in its Inspections app (launched June 15, 2026, turning spoken observations into structured findings with categories and risk levels), so it is tagged Not AI-first.
- Integrations: Billy names Procore, Autodesk, CMiC, Sage 300, Sage Intacct, Viewpoint Vista, Oracle JD Edwards, Trimble ProjectSight, Acumatica and Docusign. Highwire names Procore (syncing projects and contractors and monitoring contract spend) and a Companion integration option.
- Pricing (Billy from its Nov 9, 2026 entry; Highwire from its Nov 8, 2026 entry): Billy's FAQ says plans start as low as $500 a year and scale with the number of vendors tracked and the plan (Self Service or Managed Services, where its certificate team reviews every certificate), with a free trial. Highwire does not list prices; its pricing FAQ says pricing depends on the assessment packages and the number of contractors, that contractor subscriptions are based on headcount, and that a free trial is offered for clients. See each tool page for detail.
- Not used here: Billy policy and project counts, review ratings and customer quotes, and Highwire contractor counts, case-study results and its cost-comparison claim (vendor material). Facts for both tools come from vendor websites (desk research).
Paraphrased from the sources listed above. Vendor claims are reported as claims.
What users say
The facts above come from vendor websites. Whether either tool is any good for your work is something only people who use them can say. These are member reviews, all ratings shown, never edited or removed for being negative.
Billy
No reviews yet. Used Billy? Yours would be the first.
Highwire
No reviews yet. Used Highwire? Yours would be the first.
Used either of these? Share your take
Good or bad, an honest review from an estimator, PM or super helps the next team more than another vendor demo. You post under a handle; your email is never shown.
Questions to ask in your review
- Whether your bigger gap is ongoing insurance and document compliance during jobs (Billy's focus) or deeper financial and safety risk assessment before award (Highwire's), or both
- Whether Highwire's assessments meet your SDI carrier's prequalification requirements, and whether Billy's embedded form covers what your prequal questionnaire needs
- How each would sit alongside your accounting system and Procore, and what each costs for your number of subs
- What did you use it for, on what kind of work and project size?
- How long did setup and training take, and who on your team did it?
- What does it cost you in practice, compared with what the sales call said?
How reviews work: review guidelines and methodology. All reviews: reviews hub.
Related
- Category hub: Construction finance, payments & risk tools
- Compare: Trayd vs Miter
- Compare: Sitewire vs Built Technologies
- Compare: Highwire vs Constrafor
- Compare: TrustLayer vs Jones
- Compare: bcs vs TrustLayer
- Compare: Jones vs Constrafor
- Compare: Avetta vs ISNetworld
- Compare: ISNetworld vs Highwire
- Compare: GCPay vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: Procore Pay vs GCPay
- Compare: Clearstory vs eSUB
- Compare: Adaptive vs SuperConstruct
- Compare: Billy vs illumend
- Compare: Adaptive vs Agave
- Compare: Siteline vs SuperConstruct
- Compare: Finvari vs Speedchain
- Compare: Agave vs Morpheus
- Compare: Sage for Construction vs C/F Data Systems
- Compare: Xpedeon vs Sage for Construction
- Compare: BlueTape vs Earlytrade
- Compare: EzzyBills vs Adaptive
- Compare: Ontollo vs Datagrid
- Compare: Lumber vs Miter
- Compare: COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics vs Highwire
- Compare: Dropbox Sign for Procore vs DocuSign for Procore
- Compare: Dili vs Trayd
- Compare: bcs vs Jones
- Compare: illumend vs TrustLayer
- Compare: Billy vs TrustLayer
- Compare: EzzyBills vs Finvari
- Compare: Procore Pay vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: Constrafor vs BlueTape
- Compare: Dili vs LCPtracker
- Compare: Clearstory vs SuperConstruct
- Compare: eSUB vs Siteline
- Compare: Avetta vs COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics
- Compare: C/F Data Systems vs Xpedeon
- Compare: Morpheus vs SyncEzy
- Compare: Earlytrade vs Speedchain
- Compare: Built Technologies vs GCPay
- Compare: DocuSign for Procore vs Constructable
- Compare: Sitewire vs GCPay
- Compare: Dropbox Sign for Procore vs Constructable
- Compare: Siteline vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: Avetta vs Highwire
- Compare: Clearstory vs Rhumbix
- Compare: COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics vs ISNetworld
- Compare: Built vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: bcs vs Billy
- Compare: Procore Pay vs Siteline
- Compare: illumend vs Jones
- Compare: illumend vs bcs
- Compare: Built Technologies vs Procore Pay
- Compare: Avetta vs HammerTech
- Compare: Trayd vs LCPtracker
- Compare: eSUB vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: Billy vs Jones
- Compare: Avetta vs Veriforce
- Compare: ISNetworld vs Veriforce
- Compare: Dili vs Miter
- Compare: TrustLayer vs Constrafor: COI compliance platform or GC risk and payments suite
- Compare: Adaptive vs Built: AI accounting agents for builders or construction finance and lien waiver platform
- Compare: GCPay vs Siteline
- Compare: SuperConstruct vs GCPay
- Compare: COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics vs Pantera Tools
- Compare: EzzyBills vs Agave
- Compare: Clearstory vs Siteline
- Compare: Highwire vs Veriforce
- Compare: Avetta vs TrustLayer
- Compare: Highwire vs Pantera Tools
- Compare: Constrafor vs Veriforce
- Compare: Siteline vs Constrafor
- Compare: SuperConstruct vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: Billy vs Constrafor
- Compare: COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics vs Veriforce
- Compare: Earlytrade vs Procore Pay
- Compare: Speedchain vs Adaptive
- Compare: SyncEzy vs Agave
- Compare: Procore Pay vs SuperConstruct
- Compare: eSUB vs SuperConstruct
- Compare: Constrafor vs bcs
- Compare: Adaptive vs Siteline
- Compare: Built Technologies vs Siteline
- Compare: TrustLayer vs Highwire
- Compare: bcs vs ISNetworld
- Compare: BlueTape vs Speedchain
- Compare: Finvari vs Field Materials
- Compare: Sitewire vs BlueTape
- Compare: illumend vs Constrafor
- Compare: Adaptive vs Finvari
- Compare: Jones vs Highwire
- Compare: Veriforce vs TrustLayer
- Compare: Trayd vs Lumber
- Compare: eSUB vs Knowify
- Compare: EzzyBills vs Kojo
- Compare: Adaptive vs Constrafor
- Compare: Field Materials vs Adaptive
- Compare: Clearstory vs Raken
- Compare: eSUB vs GCPay
- Compare: Earlytrade vs GCPay
- Compare: Deltek Vantagepoint vs Xpedeon
- Compare: Constrafor vs Earlytrade
- Compare: Miter vs C/F Data Systems
- Compare: Clearstory vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: eSUB vs Procore Pay
- Compare: Billy vs COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics
- Compare: Billy vs LCPtracker
- Compare: Earlytrade vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: Adaptive vs Miter
- Compare: Highwire vs bcs
- Compare: Avetta vs Constrafor
- Compare: C/F Data Systems vs Knowify
- Compare: Clearstory vs Knowify
- Compare: Clearstory vs GCPay
- Compare: Agave vs Speedchain
- Compare: Sage for Construction vs Knowify
- Compare: Trayd vs Knowify
- Compare: Xpedeon vs Adaptive
- Compare: Avetta vs bcs
- Compare: COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics vs Constrafor
- Compare: Highwire vs HammerTech
- Compare: Adaptive vs Ontollo
- Compare: Agave vs Sage for Construction
- Compare: ISNetworld vs Jones
- Compare: Agave vs Xpedeon
- Compare: BlueTape vs Trimble Pay
- Compare: C/F Data Systems vs Agave
- Compare: Constrafor vs ISNetworld
- Compare: EzzyBills vs Field Materials
- Compare: Finvari vs Trayd
- Compare: Highwire vs illumend
- Compare: Sage for Construction vs Adaptive
- Compare: Speedchain vs EzzyBills
- Compare: C/F Data Systems vs Adaptive
- Compare: Dili vs Lumber
- Compare: Finvari vs Agave
- Compare: Jones vs Avetta
- Compare: Morpheus vs HingePoint ProConnector
- Compare: Billy vs Avetta
- Compare: Built Technologies vs SuperConstruct
- Compare: Billy vs ISNetworld
- Compare: Morpheus vs ProjectReady
- Compare: Ontollo vs CONXAI
- Compare: Clearstory vs Riskcast
- Compare: GCPay vs Adaptive
- Compare: Pantera Tools vs Constrafor
- Compare: ISNetworld vs TrustLayer
- Compare: C/F Data Systems vs Trayd
- Compare: Earlytrade vs Siteline
- Compare: Jones vs Veriforce
- Compare: bcs vs COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics
- Compare: EzzyBills vs Morpheus
- Compare: Avetta vs MSite
- Compare: BlueTape vs GCPay
- Compare: Built Technologies vs BlueTape
- Compare: COMPASS by Bespoke Metrics vs TrustLayer
- Compare: C/F Data Systems vs EzzyBills
- Compare: GCPay vs Jones
- Compare: BlueTape vs Siteline
- Compare: OrdoGrid vs EzzyBills
- Compare: GCPay vs Billy
- Compare: ISNetworld vs illumend
- Compare: Siteline vs Billy
- Compare: Veriforce vs HammerTech
- Compare: Datagrid vs Agave
- Compare: OrdoGrid vs Siteline